I was a little scared to try the Creme Eye Liners but now that I have I'm totally addicted to them. This Onyx Color has made it so easy to stop using the pencils because when I put it on I can put it on with a thick line or a thin line, I can even smudge a little before it dries to get that perfect look and it stays on all day what an exceptional product, Thanks for bringing these out and for the great Customer Service you have for convincing me to at least try them.